The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Saturday, May 25, 2013
 
India Sree Padmanabhaswamy Temple Treasure Brings Riches, Challenges and a Lot of Security
Sree Padmanabhaswamy temple in Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, India. EPA/STRINGER.

By: James Pomfret

THIRUVANANTHAPURAM (REUTERS.- A stream of bare-chested religious devotees step gingerly through metal detectors at the Sree Padmanabhaswamy temple in southern India as armed commandos with AK-47s guard perhaps one of the world's greatest treasures to surface in recent times.

For months now, following a court order to prise open subterranean vaults sealed for centuries at the heart of sleepy Thiruvananthapuram, the capital of balmy Kerala state, shell-shocked experts have been coming to terms with the vast hidden hoard, estimated at one trillion Indian rupees, or $22 billion.

In a nation where 500 million people are still mired in poverty, the find has been a revelation, stoking debate over how to best safeguard and use this newly discovered wealth at a time of financial uncertainty and modernization across India.

Put in a broader context, the find in the lush, spice-growing but relatively undeveloped Kerala, where infrastructure is patchy and per capita income lags richer northern states, could salvage the state's rickety finances, lift millions out of poverty and even help wipe out a quarter of India's overall fiscal deficit.

The treasure, an accumulation of religious offerings to the Hindu deity Lord Vishnu, includes a four-foot high gold idol studded with emeralds, gold and silver ornaments and sacks of diamonds.

"It's been a real shocker," said Manish Arora, a devotee in a white cotton mundu walking bare-foot outside the seven-storey 16th century pyramidal temple complex. "Nobody thought there'd be money like that here.

"They should use it for public welfare, for development."

But in a deeply spiritual and religious country, where even photographic documentation of the stash is barred to avoid defiling the site, any decision to remove the treasure from the temple vaults and its deity could prove highly controversial.

Some politicians, however, have suggested categorizing the treasure and selling off less historically important items like diamonds or gold bars, then investing the proceeds as part of a trust to generate steady, recurring income for social causes.

"Of course money should not be kept idle," said O. Rajagopal, a member of the Hindu nationalist opposition group, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

"It can be used in such a way that it generates more wealth and that wealth can be utilized in various useful ways like spending in education, or hospitals," he told Reuters in a small flat in Kerala.

Calls have also been made to display the treasures in a newly built museum that could prove a major tourism draw.

POLITICS, GOLD, CORRUPTION
Since the hoard came to light, Kerala's chief minister Oommen Chandy pledged to beef up security around the temple as it "naturally will be under threat."

Rather than a heist by tomb robbers, however, some fear the threat lies more with a broader malaise pervading India today as supercharged capitalism foments greater corruption in politics.

"According to my calculation this treasure constitutes only a small percentage of wealth lost in scams recently by the central government," said M. A. Baby, a leader of Kerala's Communist parties, a leading opposition force in the state.

Public anger has swollen after a spate of corruption scandals ranging from a multi-billion dollar telecoms licensing scam, shady Commonwealth Games deals and illegal mining that have triggered mass anti-graft protests and policy paralysis.

"Political people have been looting the country for so long, so how can the normal layman believe they'll safeguard this money," said Ajith Kumar, a tour guide standing in the shade outside the temple.

"The best way they can keep the money is to keep it inside the temple. That's the simplest solution."

The stash might never have come to light had not a frail 70-year-old silver-bearded devotee filed a legal petition challenging the royal family of Travancore, custodians of the temple for centuries, demanding greater transparency and better management of the long rumored, but never publicly revealed, riches sealed within six subterranean vaults.

Sundara Rajan's petition led the Kerala High Court to order the government to take over the assets, but the royal family appealed to India's Supreme Court, the country's highest court, that ordered a detailed inventory and expert reports on the treasure, before making a judgment expected in October.

The success of the petition is a testament to India's strong legal tradition compared with fellow Asian economic powerhouse China, where individuals often struggle for justice in the face of corrupt officials, pliable judges and a stability-obsessed ruling Communist Party.

While the stash hasn't become a major political controversy yet, there have been precedents in India for religious sites becoming wider social flashpoints.

The Ayodhya mosque in northern India, demolished by rampaging Hindu mobs in 1992, sparked bloody clashes that killed around 2000 people, and an ongoing legal battle for control over the disputed religious site.

As India globalizes and swelling middle classes become increasingly materialistic, underlying religious beliefs remain deep-rooted in the world's largest democracy of 1.2 billion people, where 80 percent are Hindus and 13 percent are Muslims.

"Now we are fearful," said Anju Parvathy, dressed in a dark blue sari and gold ornaments on her doorstep near the temple's north gate. "We don't want the gold. It's god's property."

The courts, aware of the risk of fanning religious sensitivities, are unlikely to order a total redistribution of the temple wealth, but broker a judicious compromise between all the different interests.

"The supreme court is the final authority of the country, they can take any decision, the government has to comply with it," minister Chandy told Reuters in his office in a historic building not far from the temple.

PROPERTY RIGHTS TO GODS
Yet despite India's secular constitution and modernity, its laws grant property rights to gods.

Indian law carries provisions for deities to effectively own property, meaning the $22 billion worth of offerings made to Lord Vishnu at the temple could remain sealed in the vaults.

"This treasure belongs not to the state, not to the maharajah, not to the people at large, it belongs to the deity only," said the BJP's Rajagopal.

Rajagopal said it was possible using astrological methods to divine the will of the deity on how to potentially invest or divest part of the treasure.

"That deity can own property and can sell property so the whole property belongs to the deity," he added.

Moving forward, however, even traditionalists acknowledge a need for an evolution of India's social and religious fabric.

"We have to move with the modern world. At the same time we want to keep the values also," said M.G. Sasibhooshan, a historian seen to be close to the royal family of Travancore.

"Religion is a great force. It has a role in evolving ethics. Striking a balance between religion and change is the idea for an Indian," he said. "But it's not easy."

(Editing by Elaine Lies)



Last Week News

August 19, 2011

Museu de Arte de Sao Paulo Brings Eight Artists to Brazil for Site Specific Interventions

Archaeologists in Georgia Comb Newly-Found Civil War Prisoner of War Camp for Artifacts

Qing Dynasty Porcelain and Snuff Bottles Highlight Bonhams August Asian Decorative Art Sale

The Richard Gere Guitar Collection to Be Offered at Christie's New York in October

Global Auction House Christie's Growth in Asia Continues with New Senior Appointments

Times Square Alliance and mmmm. Unveil the World Premiere of "Meeting Bowls" in Times Square

Sotheby's to Sell Rediscovered Work by Vilhelm Hammershoi, A Study for The Coin Collector in Oslo Museum

Museum Receives $7.6 Million Bequest from the Estate of Leonard and Bebe Levine

Pipilotti Rist Curates Sommerakademie 2011: An Annual International Platform for Contemporary Art

Fenella France Named Chief, Preservation Research and Testing Division at the Library of Congress

First American Printed Bible and First Edition Book of Mormon Headline Heritage Rare Books Auction

Connecticut Police Probe Theft of Two Tang Dynasty Chinese Sculptures Stored in Westport

Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology Wins $150,000 Grant for Archaeological Collection

A Dynasty of Wine: The Estate of Award-Winning Actor John Forsythe at Bonhams

ArtBerkshires Presents a Weekend of Curated Lectures, Performances, and Activities

Blacklots, The First Daily Art Auction Website, Launches!

MIT Published Author Switches to Kindle Direct Publishing-Platform

Egypt Uprising Art Brightens Cairo, Tempts Buyers

August 18, 2011

Jeff Bezos Donates $10 Million to Create "Center for Innovation" at New Museum in Seattle

New Series of Articles: How to Work with Art-Level Antique Oriental Rugs as Interior Design Center Pieces

The Hunt for Hidden Gems Begins on the Series Premiere of "Buried Treasure"

Detectives Seek Thieves Who Swiped Rembrandt Sketch from Lobby of a Seaside Hotel

Since It Opened Four Weeks Ago, Museum of Liverpool has Welcomed 250,000 Visitors

Israel Antiquities Authority Announces Restoration of the "Crown" in Damascus Gate

Early American Militaria to Highlight Bonhams & Butterfields' Fall Arms and Armor Sale

MoMA's Annual Photography Series Highlights Six Emerging Contemporary Artists

Oscar Winner Whoopi Goldberg to Offer Selections from Her Personal Collection at Heritage Auctions

Moscow Biennale of Contemporary Art Announces Final List of Participants        

Mariana Cook Examines One of Man's Earliest and Most Enduring Methods of Defining Territories

Moby Dick: The Fastest Motorcycle of the 1920s to Be Auctioned at Bonhams' Sale in Staffordshire

Jonathan Ferrara Gallery Presents New Photographs and Video Works by Generic Art Solutions

Postal Stamp Honors Hollywood Director John Huston

Los Angeles Modern Auctions to Present Exhibition During Pacific Standard Time

The Affordable Art Fair to Land in Los Angeles in January 2012

Dutch Museums May Sell Treasures to Make Ends Meet

Asia's Wealthy Park Cash in Cars, Homes, Art and Wine

Smithsonian Scientists Discover the Most Primitive Living Eel, Creating a New Species

August 17, 2011

Too Hot to Handle: 350-Year-Old Stolen Rembrandt Found at California Church

A Selection of Murals Made by Diego Rivera During the 1930s to Be Shown at MoMA

National Gallery of Victoria Acquires Newly Discovered Renaissance Masterpiece

Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art Acquires Key Work by Margaret Macdonald Mackintosh

Australia's First Online "Dress Register" is Launched by the Powerhouse Museum

Hapsburg Imperial Treasures Go on Display in Cambridge with Lost Royal Masterpiece

Site-Specific Artworks by Leading British Artists Alight on Northamptonshire's Waterways

Academy Art Museum in Maryland Features the Work of Richard Paul Weiblinger and Jan Matulka

Preview Berlin: The Emerging Art Fair 2011 to Present an Internationally Oriented Group of Exhibitors

Linz Native Sam Auinger to Be Featured Artist at the Ars Electronica 2011 Festival

Art San Diego's Art Labs to Feature 19 Projects by More than 150 Artists Throughout San Diego

Bruce Munro's First One-Man Show: 'Light!' Announced at Longwood Gardens

Japan's Tsunami-Hit Towns Fight to Sustain Folk Arts; Artists Determined to Go On

German Artist Nicola Dill's Sea Etchings Extended at Rose Gallery

Huge Diamond Forfeited in Ohio to Be Auctioned

Young Artists Sought for Cultural Olympiad Finale

Associated Press Photographer Portrays Mayan Women with Vintage Box Camera Bought in Afghanistan

Missing Ohio Ballpark Statue Found at Police Department

Virginia Slavery Museum Group Misses Tax Deadline

August 16, 2011

Dutch City Settles on Looted Jan Steen Painting "The Marriage of Tobias and Sarah"

A Rare Statue of Hercules was Found at Horvat Tarbenet in the Jezreel Valley   

Freer Gallery of Art to Open the Shutters of James McNeill Whistler's Famed Peacock Room

Rijksmuseum to Open Exhibition at the Schiphol Airport of Top Models of the Dutch Golden Age

Between Film and Art: Storyboards from Hitchcock to Spielberg Exhibited in Berlin

Museum of Biblical Art Exhibition Celebrates the 400th Anniversary of the King James Bible

First Contemporary Middle Eastern Art Auction Announced at Artnet Auctions     

Tomasso Brothers Fine Art Announce Participation at the International Fine Art & Antique Dealers Show

Following Its Successful Debut Last Year, Moniker Art Fair 2011 Announces 2011 Gallery Line-up

Smithsonian Hosts Symposium Exploring Indigenous Roots of Caribbean Culture

Rarities From Antiquity and Around the World Anchor September Long Beach World Coin Auction

Old Text, New Wrinkles: Did Notorious Old West Outlaw Butch Cassidy Survive?

Gold Coin Brings $1,322,500 as Top Lot in $31+ Million Chicago Rare U.S. Coin Event from Heritage Auctions

Jessica Stockholder Utilizes Wood from Tree to Create a New Project at the Aldrich

Smithsonian American Art Museum Announces 2011-2012 Fellowship Appointments

A New Approach on the Rembrandt Drawing Stolen from California Hotel

Police: Woman Attacks Art at DC Museum Again

August 15, 2011

Karin Sander Awarded the 2011 Hans Thoma Prize, the Grand State Prize for Fine Arts

Exhibition at Albertina Museum Provides Insights into Max Weiler's Entire Drawing Career

Danish Audiences Get a Chance to Experience in Exhibition, a New Side of Josef Albers

New Exhibition at the Dallas Museum of Art Explores the Artistry of African Headwear

Summer Exhibition at the Belvedere Focuses on Josef Danhauser's Pictorial Narratives

German Artist Georg Baselitz Introduces a New Artistic Device into His Art: The Remix

Sovereign Splendour: Imperial Porcelain from Shanghai at the Gemeentemuseum Den Haag

Photographic Memory: The Album in the Age of Photography by Verna Posever Curtis

During 'Elvis Week,' Fans Flock to Memphis to Remember Pivotal Year in Singer's Career

Chasing Shadows: Thirty Years of Photographic Essay by Santu Mofoken at Jeu de Paume

Revolutionary Icon Fidel Castro Turns 85 Quietly but Still a Force in the Island of Cuba

Exhibition at Hamburg's Kunstverein Features Several Installation Settings by Berlin-Based Artist Henning Bohl

Deichtorhallen Hamburg Showcases the Versatile Oeuvre of Zurich Artist and Polymath Dieter Meier

Outdoor Sculpture by Thomas Houseago at the Royal Botanic Garden in Edinburgh

PDNB Gallery Examines One Collector's Idea of Meaningful Objects in New Exhibition

Olaf Nicolai Transforms the Staircase in the Pinakothek der Moderne into a Stage

Art Thieves Nab $250,000 Rembrandt from California Hotel

Belvedere Worker Fired for Washing Himself with Own Urine

August 14, 2011

Once Divided Germany Marks Bitter 50th Anniversary of the Construction of the Berlin Wall

Art of the Western World: Illuminating PBS Documentary Series Release Announced

Frank Stella: Wall Sculptures Inspired by Archaeological Sites in Ancient Anatolia

U.S. Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar Announces Statue of Liberty to Close for Yearlong Repairs

Dirty Pictures Exhibition by Nathaniel Ward and Timothy Bergstrom at the HungryMan Gallery

Marrakech Art Fair Announces It will Offer a Broader View on The Artistic Emerging Scenes

Yoshua Okón Blurs the Lines Between Documentary, Reality, and Fiction at the Hammer Museum

New and Recent Works by Ruth Ewan in First Major Show at Dundee Contemporary Arts

Dual Nature: Science Illustrations of Dan Otte at the Academy of Natural Sciences

Guggenheim Museum's Ultra Rare "Art Car" Inspired BMW to be Sold at Quail Lodge

Los Angeles' Most Famous Landmark, the Hollywood Sign, Has Neighbors Fuming at Tourist Invasion

New York Photographer Richard Rothman Announces New Book: Redwood Saw

First Institutional Solo Exhibition of Swiss Artist Marianne Flotron at Kunsthalle Bern

MOCA GA Working Artist Project Winner, Micah Stansell, to Premier The Water and The Blood Exhibition

Polish/Canadian Artist Andrzej Maciejewski Presents Garden of Eden at the Camerawork Gallery in Portland

New Website Targets Teachers and Students to Study Native Responses to Environmental Challenges

Artist Pablo Bronstein Introduces Ballet at the Institute of Contemporary Arts

Eras Clash on Nevada's Comstock

South Mountain Museum Upgrades Planned in Maryland

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Jackson Pollock work "Number 19, 1948" sells for record $58.4 million at Christie's

2.- Exhibition of nude photography around 1900 on view at Berlin's Photography Museum

3.- Belize City officials say ancient thirty-meter high Mayan pyramid razed for road fill

4.- Hidden drawings from Nazi concentration camp on display at Jewish Museum in Berlin

5.- Records fall at Sotheby's contemporary art auction; Barnett Newman painting sells for $43.84M

6.- Death mask of Napoleon to be auctioned at Bonhams' Book, Map and Manuscript sale

7.- New Yorkers unnerved by neighbor's voyeuristic photos on view at Julie Saul Gallery

8.- Rare Vincent Van Gogh sketchbook copies up for unprecedented sale at museum store and online

9.- Leonardo DiCaprio environmental art auction at Christie's New York tops $38 million

10.- Hong Kong cries fowl as giant rubber duck by Dutch artist Florentijn Hofman deflates



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Web Developer: Gabriel Sifuentes - Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi
Special Advisor: Carlos Amador - Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias
Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site